The Art of Abduction

Hypothesis competition beyond mutual exclusivity . Philosophy of Science 84 : 810-824 . Schupbach , J. N. & Sprenger , J. ( 2011 ) . The logic of explanatory power . Philosophy of Science 78 : 105–127 . Schurz , G ...

The Art of Abduction

A novel defense of abduction, one of the main forms of nondeductive reasoning. With this book, Igor Douven offers the first comprehensive defense of abduction, a form of nondeductive reasoning. Abductive reasoning, which is guided by explanatory considerations, has been under normative pressure since the advent of Bayesian approaches to rationality. Douven argues that, although it deviates from Bayesian tenets, abduction is nonetheless rational. Drawing on scientific results, in particular those from reasoning research, and using computer simulations, Douven addresses the main critiques of abduction. He shows that versions of abduction can perform better than the currently popular Bayesian approaches—and can even do the sort of heavy lifting that philosophers have hoped it would do. Douven examines abduction in detail, comparing it to other modes of inference, explaining its historical roots, discussing various definitions of abduction given in the philosophical literature, and addressing the problem of underdetermination. He looks at reasoning research that investigates how judgments of explanation quality affect people’s beliefs and especially their changes of belief. He considers the two main objections to abduction, the dynamic Dutch book argument, and the inaccuracy-minimization argument, and then gives abduction a positive grounding, using agent-based models to show the superiority of abduction in some contexts. Finally, he puts abduction to work in a well-known underdetermination argument, the argument for skepticism regarding the external world.

More Books:

Philosophy of Science
Language: en
Pages: 460
Authors: Gerhard Schurz
Categories: Philosophy
Type: BOOK - Published: 2013-11-20 - Publisher: Routledge

Philosophy of Science: A Unified Approach combines a general introduction to philosophy of science with an integrated survey of all its important subfields. As the book’s subtitle suggests, this excellent overview is guided methodologically by "a unified approach" to philosophy of science: behind the diversity of scientific fields one can
Erkenntnis Orientated: A Centennial Volume for Rudolf Carnap and Hans Reichenbach
Language: en
Pages: 471
Authors: W. Spohn
Categories: Science
Type: BOOK - Published: 2012-12-06 - Publisher: Springer Science & Business Media

Rudolf Carnap was born on May 18, 1891, and Hans Reichenbach on September 26 in the same year. They are two of the greatest philosophers of this century, and they are eminent representatives of what is perhaps the most powerful contemporary philosophical movement. Moreover, they founded the journal Erkenntnis. This
Springer Handbook of Model-Based Science
Language: en
Pages: 1180
Authors: Lorenzo Magnani, Tommaso Bertolotti
Categories: Technology & Engineering
Type: BOOK - Published: 2017-05-22 - Publisher: Springer

This handbook offers the first comprehensive reference guide to the interdisciplinary field of model-based reasoning. It highlights the role of models as mediators between theory and experimentation, and as educational devices, as well as their relevance in testing hypotheses and explanatory functions. The Springer Handbook merges philosophical, cognitive and epistemological
The Art of Abduction
Language: en
Pages: 370
Authors: Igor Douven
Categories: Philosophy
Type: BOOK - Published: 2022-05-03 - Publisher: MIT Press

A novel defense of abduction, one of the main forms of nondeductive reasoning. With this book, Igor Douven offers the first comprehensive defense of abduction, a form of nondeductive reasoning. Abductive reasoning, which is guided by explanatory considerations, has been under normative pressure since the advent of Bayesian approaches to
Patrick Suppes: Scientific Philosopher
Language: en
Pages: 344
Authors: P. Humphreys
Categories: Mathematics
Type: BOOK - Published: 1994-09-30 - Publisher: Springer Science & Business Media

Patrick Suppes is a philosopher and scientist whose contributions range over probability and statistics, mathematical and experimental psychology, the foundations of physics, education theory, the philosophy of language, measurement theory, and the philosophy of science. He has also been a pioneer in the area of computer assisted instruction. In each